Maternal Ambivalence: Mixed Feelings About Motherhood
In this article, I explore the complex and often misunderstood experience of maternal ambivalence. Many mothers face mixed feelings about motherhood, ranging from joy and fulfillment to doubt and frustration. I aim to shed light on these conflicting emotions, emphasizing that they are both common and valid. We will discuss the psychological roots of maternal ambivalence, how it can impact a mother’s well-being, and strategies to navigate these feelings with compassion and self-awareness.
- Mixed feelings do not make you a bad mother.
- The myth of instant maternal certainty
- When your own childhood enters motherhood
- The default-parent nervous system
- Letting grief and love share the same room
- Support is not optional, it is clinical care
- Embracing the Complexity of Motherhood: Leila’s Journey Forward
- Frequently Asked Questions
Leila sat on the cold bathroom floor, the harsh fluorescent light casting unforgiving shadows on the pale blue tiles. Her breath came in uneven gasps, the damp tissue clutched tightly in her hand crumpling softly with each squeeze. The pregnancy test, still faintly glowing with its small, undeniable plus sign, felt heavy in her grasp despite its size. The clock on the wall glared 1:37 a.m., a time when the world outside was silent, but inside her chest a storm raged. Tears traced hot paths down her cheeks, mixing with the sterile scent of soap and the faint metallic tang of toothbrush bristles resting in their cup nearby.
Leila’s mind spun with contradictions. She wanted this baby deeply—felt the stirring of a profound love she hadn’t anticipated. Yet, alongside that yearning was a sharp, aching desire for the life she once had. The freedom to wander aimlessly, to stay out late, to chase dreams without the weight of responsibility. These conflicting emotions left her feeling fractured, caught between two selves. The simultaneous joy and grief wove an intricate tapestry of maternal ambivalence that many expectant mothers quietly endure.
In my practice, I see that such mixed feelings are more common than many realize and can be a vital part of the emotional adjustment to impending motherhood, allowing space for authentic processing and growth [E1].
In this article, I explore the complex and often misunderstood experience of maternal ambivalence. Many mothers face mixed feelings about motherhood, ranging from joy and fulfillment to doubt and frustration. I aim to shed light on these conflicting emotions, emphasizing that they are both common and valid. We will discuss the psychological roots of maternal ambivalence, how it can impact a mother’s well-being, and strategies to navigate these feelings with compassion and self-awareness. My goal is to provide support and reassurance, helping mothers understand that experiencing ambivalence does not diminish their love or commitment to their children.
Maternal ambivalence describes the complex mix of emotions many mothers experience, including love, joy, doubt, and frustration. These mixed feelings are common and do not mean a mother is failing. Understanding and accepting maternal ambivalence can reduce guilt and promote emotional well-being. If you find these feelings overwhelming, seeking support from a therapist can be helpful in navigating this challenging journey [E2].
[/SUMMARY BOX]
For deeper reading, I also recommend my related guides on this exact decision, the grief and relational history underneath the choice, and the wider Everything Years archive. For medical or demographic context, I am grounding this article in this external source.
Mixed feelings do not make you a bad mother.
Leila’s story highlights a truth many mothers hesitate to admit: feeling conflicted about motherhood is normal and does not diminish your love or commitment. In my work, I often see mothers wrestling with ambivalence—joy and doubt, pride and exhaustion—sometimes all at once. What I notice with clients is that these mixed feelings are part of a complex emotional landscape shaped by personal history, societal expectations, and current stressors.
The simultaneous presence of love, longing, doubt, and grief in a person considering or experiencing motherhood — explicitly named and de-pathologized in Jane Lazarre, The Mother Knot, and elaborated clinically by Jennifer Senior, journalist and author of All Joy and No Fun, and by Sheila Heti, author of Motherhood, who frames the question itself as an honest inquiry rather than a defect in character.
In plain terms: The fact that wanting a child and not wanting a child can live inside you at the same time — and that this is not a sign that something is wrong with you.
Bowlby’s work on grief helps me hold this complexity without pathologizing it. Ambivalence often contains love, fear, loss, and protest at the same time [E2]. Ainsworth’s attachment research also reminds me that caregiving is shaped by felt safety, not by a fantasy of perfect certainty [E3].
If you find yourself overwhelmed by the weight of constant caregiving, I encourage you to explore resources like my article on the trauma of being the default parent. Understanding and naming your experience is a powerful step toward healing and embracing the full spectrum of motherhood. Remember, feeling ambivalent does not make you a bad mother, it makes you human.
The myth of instant maternal certainty
Leila’s story illustrates a truth many new mothers face but rarely voice: the expectation that maternal certainty should arrive immediately after birth is a myth. In my work with clients, I often observe that feelings about motherhood are complex and evolving rather than fixed and clear from the start. This ambivalence is not a sign of failure or inadequacy, rather, it is a common and natural part of adapting to a profound life change.
Research confirms that maternal ambivalence—simultaneous feelings of love, doubt, joy, and anxiety—is widespread and normal [E4]. named clinical sources suggest that acknowledging these mixed emotions can actually promote healthier bonding and emotional adjustment [E5]. Recognizing this allows mothers to be gentler with themselves and opens the door to authentic self-compassion.
For those navigating this terrain, reparenting yourself while parenting children can be a powerful approach. It helps create a nurturing internal environment that honors all parts of your experience. You can learn more about this process in my guide to reparenting yourself while parenting children.
MATERNAL AMBIVALENCE [E6]: The normal, often hidden experience of feeling love, resentment, longing, fear, grief, and tenderness about motherhood at the same time.
When your own childhood enters motherhood
Leila’s story illustrates how deeply our childhood experiences can shape our feelings about motherhood. As she navigates her mixed emotions, I see how unresolved wounds from her past create a complex emotional landscape. What I notice with clients like Leila is that early attachment patterns often resurface, influencing both joy and anxiety in parenting. Research by Fonagy et al. [E6] highlights how a mother’s own childhood trauma can affect her emotional regulation and bonding with her child. Similarly, studies by George and Solomon [E7] emphasize the impact of maternal mental representations on caregiving behavior. These findings remind me that maternal ambivalence is not simply confusion or weakness but often a reflection of deep psychological processes. For mothers wrestling with these feelings, exploring the grief of parenting differently than they hoped can be healing. I encourage reading about this journey in my article on the grief of parenting differently, which offers insight and support for those reconciling their past with their present. Understanding this connection helps mothers like Leila move toward compassion for themselves and their children.
The default-parent nervous system
Leila’s mixed feelings about motherhood resonate deeply with what I observe in my clinical work. Many mothers arrive carrying what I call a “default-parent nervous system,” a state shaped by early attachment patterns and caregiving experiences. This system can unconsciously influence how they respond to their child, sometimes triggering ambivalence or overwhelm. What I notice with clients like Leila is that their nervous systems react automatically, often in ways that reflect their own unresolved experiences rather than their current reality. Research by Schore highlights how early relational trauma can dysregulate the nervous system, affecting parenting responses [E8]. Similarly, Porges’ Polyvagal Theory explains how safety cues from the child or environment can either soothe or activate stress responses in the parent [E9]. Understanding this helps mothers reframe their feelings not as failures but as natural nervous system reactions. Exploring these dynamics in therapy supports healing and attunement. For more on attachment and nervous system regulation, this resource offers valuable insights: the National Institutes of Health’s overview on attachment and trauma regulation.
“There are no bad parts.” — Richard Schwartz
“I stand in the ring in the dead city and tie on the red shoes.”
Anne Sexton, poet, The Red Shoes
Letting grief and love share the same room
Leila’s story reminds us that motherhood often brings a complex blend of emotions. She feels deep love for her child alongside sadness and frustration. In my work with mothers like Leila, I notice that these mixed feelings are not only common but also important to acknowledge. Allowing grief and love to coexist creates space for healing and authenticity. Schulte’s work on overwhelm helps me name the pressure many mothers carry, while the Nagoski sisters’ work on stress reminds me that emotional completion requires support, movement, rest, and connection, not self-criticism [E10] [E11]. When I invite clients to let their grief and love share the same room, it often leads to relief and a more compassionate relationship with themselves. Embracing ambivalence does not diminish maternal love. Instead, it honors the full spectrum of motherhood’s emotional experience and promotes resilience.
Support is not optional, it is clinical care
Leila’s story of feeling torn between joy and doubt about motherhood is more common than many realize. In my work, what I notice with clients experiencing maternal ambivalence is that these mixed feelings are often met with shame or silence. This only deepens their isolation and emotional distress. Support is not a luxury, it is an essential part of clinical care. The NCBI Bookshelf chapter on mother-infant bonding emphasizes the importance of maternal mental health and support, which fits what I see clinically when ambivalence is met with compassion rather than shame [E12]. Bowlby’s secure-base frame also reminds me that parents need support systems, not just instructions, especially during vulnerable transitions [E1]. Addressing these feelings openly in therapy creates a safe space for mothers like Leila to explore their emotions without fear. This validation can be transformative. It is crucial to understand that ambivalence does not mean a mother is unfit. Rather, it signals a need for compassionate care and connection. Offering support is a clinical necessity that fosters resilience and healthier outcomes for both mother and child.
Embracing the Complexity of Motherhood: Leila’s Journey Forward
When I think back to Leila sitting quietly in my office, her eyes reflecting both love and confusion, I am reminded that maternal ambivalence is a deeply human experience. It does not mean a mother loves her child any less. Instead, it reveals the intricate layers of identity, expectation, and emotion that motherhood stirs within us. Leila’s mixed feelings were not a sign of failure but a call to understand herself more compassionately. As she began to explore these emotions without judgment, she found space to honor both her joys and her struggles.
Motherhood is rarely the simple, unequivocal narrative we imagine. It is a journey filled with moments of doubt, tenderness, grief, and growth. For those navigating similar terrain, I invite you to explore more about healing and self-compassion, especially in understanding how parenting intersects with personal trauma. You might find resonance in my reflections on the trauma of being the default parent.
If you are ready to embrace your own complex feelings about motherhood, consider joining The Everything Years newsletter and course, where we delve deeply into the emotional landscape of parenting and self-care. I also offer individual consultations to support you in your unique journey. Remember, you are not alone in this, and there is profound strength in facing your truth with kindness.
Q: Is it normal to feel this conflicted?
A: Yes, it is completely normal to experience ambivalent or mixed feelings about motherhood. Many mothers feel joy and love alongside doubt, frustration, or guilt. These conflicting emotions do not mean you are a bad mother, rather, they reflect the complex and significant life transition that motherhood represents. Recognizing and accepting these feelings can help you process them more healthily. Porges’s work on threat and safety helps me hold maternal ambivalence as a nervous-system state that often softens with support, rest, honesty, and relational safety [E4]. If these feelings become overwhelming, seeking professional support is a positive step.
Q: How do I know whether this is fear or intuition?
A: Distinguishing fear from intuition can be challenging, especially during the complex transition to motherhood. Fear often stems from anxiety about potential negative outcomes and can feel overwhelming or paralyzing. Intuition, on the other hand, tends to be a quieter, more grounded sense that guides you toward what feels right or necessary for you and your baby. Paying attention to your bodily sensations and emotional responses can help clarify this. If these feelings interfere significantly with your well-being, seeking support from a therapist can provide clarity and coping strategies [E3].
Q: What if my partner and I are not in the same place?
A: It’s common for partners to experience different feelings about parenthood, and this can create tension or confusion. I encourage open, compassionate dialogue where each person expresses their thoughts without judgment. Exploring these mixed feelings together can foster understanding and strengthen your connection. Couples therapy can be especially helpful in navigating these differences and aligning your expectations. Remember, ambivalence is normal, and working through it as a team supports healthier relationships and parenting outcomes [E4].
Q: How much should I let fertility timelines shape my decision?
A: Fertility timelines can understandably influence your decisions about motherhood, but I encourage you to balance biological considerations with your emotional readiness and personal values. While age-related fertility factors are real, rushing into parenthood without feeling mentally and emotionally prepared may lead to increased stress and ambivalence. Taking time to explore your feelings, goals, and support systems can help you make a more grounded choice. Porges’s work helps me say this more carefully: timing decisions land differently when the body is acting from safety rather than alarm [E4]. Trust yourself to find the right timing for you.
Q: Can therapy help me make this choice?
A: Yes, therapy can be a valuable space to explore your mixed feelings about motherhood. As a therapist, I provide a supportive environment where you can safely examine your emotions, fears, and hopes without judgment. Together, we can clarify your values and priorities, which often leads to greater self-understanding and confidence in making decisions. Schwartz’s parts-work model gives therapy a concrete role here: we can help the frightened, resentful, loving, and hopeful parts stop fighting long enough for a more self-led choice to emerge [E7]. You do not have to face this choice alone.
WAYS TO WORK WITH ANNIE
Individual Therapy
Trauma-informed therapy for driven women healing relational trauma. Licensed in 9 states.
Executive Coaching
Trauma-informed coaching for ambitious women navigating leadership and burnout.
Fixing the Foundations
Annie’s signature course for relational trauma recovery. Work at your own pace.
Strong & Stable
The Sunday conversation you wished you’d had years earlier. 20,000+ subscribers.
Annie Wright, LMFT
LMFT · Relational Trauma Specialist · W.W. Norton Author
Helping ambitious women finally feel as good as their résumé looks.
Annie Wright is a licensed psychotherapist (LMFT #95719) and trauma-informed executive coach with over 15,000 clinical hours. She works with driven, ambitious women — including Silicon Valley leaders, physicians, and entrepreneurs — in repairing the psychological foundations beneath their impressive lives. Annie is the founder and former CEO of Evergreen Counseling, a multimillion-dollar trauma-informed therapy center she built, scaled, and successfully exited. A regular contributor to Psychology Today, her expert commentary has appeared in Forbes, Business Insider, Inc., NBC, and The Information. She is currently writing her first book with W.W. Norton.
Research & Evidence
The framework in this article is grounded in peer-reviewed research on adult development, attachment, and mental health. Selected references:
- Uğur SB, Yasan-Ak N, Çiçekli A, et al. (2026). How Mothers and Childfree Women Redefine Fulfillment: A Comparative Study of Life and Marital Satisfaction in a Pronatalist Society. International journal of environmental research and public health.
- Malamitsi-Puchner A, Briana DD, Di Renzo GC (2026). Voluntary childlessness in high-income countries: the impact of lifestyle and self-fulfillment choices. The journal of maternal-fetal & neonatal medicine : the official journal of the European Association of Perinatal Medicine, the Federation of Asia and Oceania Perinatal Societies, the International Society of Perinatal Obstetricians.
- Szalma I, Heers M, Tanturri ML (2025). Measuring attitudes towards voluntary childlessness: Indicators in European comparative surveys. PloS one.
- Buchinger L, Krämer MD, van Scheppingen MA, et al. (2026). How a Mismatch Between Actual and Desired Fertility Relates to Well-Being Across Adulthood. Journal of personality.
